Aircard vs. Satellite Internet

by Michael Hintz

Many rural computer owners are still without conventional broadband internet options, but alternate kinds are available in the forms of satellites and mobile aircards. Although both provide broadband-like speeds, each has its own limitations.

Speed

Satellite internet download speeds should reach at least 500kbps, and might go as high as 1000kbps, making it leagues faster than dial-up. Aircards typically are about two to three times faster than dial-up, but can achieve speeds comparable to satellite if within EV-DO range (EV-DO is the mobile broadband standard).

Coverage

Satellite internet can be had anywhere that has a clear view of the southern sky (or of the northern sky if in the southern hemisphere), but aircard coverage is limited to cell tower coverage. Check providers’ websites for coverage charts to determine aircard coverage in your area.

Latency

Aircard internet has much better latency (how often data transmissions are sent over a network connection) than satellite internet because data only needs to travel to the nearest cell tower and not the 44,480 miles into orbit and back that satellite connections require. Satellite connections offset this by increasing the amount of data sent in each transmission.

Price

Satellite internet services range from about $50 a month up to well over $200 a month for premium-quality connections, not including equipment and installation costs. Aircard internet services usually cost around $60 a month.

Download Limitations

Both options will likely include download limitations. Satellite providers limit download volume on a daily, weekly, or monthly basis, reducing connections to dial-up speeds if these limits are exceeded. Aircard internet services may advertise unlimited, but will likely start charging extra after a download quota for the month has been reached.

Networking Options

Although satellite internet can typically be shared over a home network as any other broadband connection can, one of aircards’ limitations is that home networking is a problem because the aircard connects directly to a computer and not through an external modem.

About the Author

Michael Hintz is a technically inclined individual with a penchant for the English language. Having recently graduated from Eastern Michigan University, where he wrote for the school's newspaper, he is now looking for full-time writing and editing work while building his online writing portfolio at sites like eHow and Answerbag.

Photo Credits

  • photo_camera Pixland/Pixland/Getty Images